The Wild Fishing Forum

Open Forums => Open Boards Viewable By Guests => Publications => Topic started by: Fierybroon on February 04, 2006, 09:15:31 PM

Title: The Scottish Fishing Book
Post by: Fierybroon on February 04, 2006, 09:15:31 PM
This is an excellent reference book for the beginner and a wealth of information on where to fish,contacts and prices etc.Beautiful pictures and covers all types of fishing to be had in Scotland.If bought in person from
John R. Gows in Dundee can even be personally signed by the auther.A great read for whatever level you are at!!!


(http://wildfisher.co.uk/uploads/1842040200-2006Feb041139084237.jpg)
Title: The Scottish Fishing Book
Post by: nikkitam on May 22, 2006, 10:48:51 PM
i'll second fierybroon's recomendation - i bought my copy in the edinburgh wool mill in moffat
Title: The Scottish Fishing Book
Post by: Fierybroon on May 23, 2006, 06:27:46 PM
If you take your copy down to Gow's in Dundee you can get it signed.
Title: The Scottish Fishing Book
Post by: Wildfisher on May 23, 2006, 07:22:13 PM
Sorry chaps, but I must say this is not  a book I rate especially highly. If it is aimed at beginners then I must question the wisdom of including a photo of an angler standing while fishing from  a boat on Loch Lee.
Title: The Scottish Fishing Book
Post by: deergravy on May 23, 2006, 10:43:35 PM
Fred,
I think that's a wee bit harsh, condemning a book on the basis of one picture.
But I can see why you were peeved - whenever I see people standing up in a boat to fish I think "these clowns don't know what they're doing". It's dangerous and counter-productive.
For a tenner, I'd say the book was worth having, lots of nice pictures, no great revelations as far as fishing methods go.
Probably aimed at the "relatives of fishermen, looking for a cheap present" market and as such does quite a pleasing job.
Dave
Title: The Scottish Fishing Book
Post by: Wildfisher on May 23, 2006, 10:51:05 PM
Dave,  I am not condemning the book over one picture – in fact I am not condemning it at all really, just saying I don't rate it that highly.   It's just not my kind of read I suppose. The photos were good, pity about the plonker standing in the boat. On a wee shallow loch that's OK, but on a glacial loch  like loch lee it is bloody daft. If you fall in there you are in trouble. Too many folk have been drowned due to standing  in boats.

Odd you should mention it thouhg, I do believe I got the book as a present!   :D